Yet another reason the ORPP is a bad idea

Given that most Ontarians are well-prepared for retirement, the ORPP is a solution in search of a problem.

Ontario pension plan is unnecessary—and will result in lower wages

Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne has reiterated her government’s commitment to push ahead with a provincial pension plan.

Rethink Ontario’s unnecessary and counterproductive pension plan

The Ontario government claims the ORPP is necessary because we aren’t saving enough for retirement, but a number of recent studies show there is no retirement savings crisis in Canada.

When designing Ontario’s new pension plan, look to Australia

As the Ontario government moves ahead with plans for a new mandatory provincial pension program in January 2017, early signs suggest the program will be largely modelled after the Canada Pension Plan. Ontarians, however, would benefit from a broader debate that looks beyond their borders.

Printer-friendly version
Lessons for Ontario and Canada from Forced Retirement Saving Mandates in Australia

Ontario is set to enact a new forced retirement saving mandate through the Ontario Retirement Pension Plan (ORPP), coming into effect January 1, 2017, as the country as a whole continues to debate expanding the Canada Pension Plan (CPP). While it isn’t clear that additional compulsory mandates are even needed, this paper argues that if Canadian governments proceed with such initiatives, they should consider Australia’s system of individual retirement saving accounts instead of restricting the option to Canada’s CPP model.

This bulletin compares the main features of the Australian and Canadian retirement income systems, primarily focusing on the compulsory saving mandates built into the two systems. The fundamental difference is that Australia’s superannuation system is based on individual accounts compared to Canada’s collective CPP, upon which the new ORPP will be modelled.

Australia’s defined contribution system, which has much in common with Canada’s RRSPs, offers several advantages over the defined benefit CPP and ORPP. For instance, contributions to the superannuation accounts fully vest to the individual and can be bequeathed on death. Superannuation account balances can also be withdrawn without penalty in cases of severe financial hardship, to meet the cost of medical expenses, and in the case of terminal illness.

Australia’s superannuation accounts have limited rules around asset allocation and investment strategy, affording account holders considerable flexibility; individuals may choose a different investment strategy based on their preferences and circumstances. Superannuation accounts can avoid some of the underfunding risks associated with partially funded, defined benefit schemes.

Subscribe to RSS - ORPP